ɛuɳιсe. ♀ ™

NO GUARENTEES!!~ This is a reference.. not a full list yet.. will update this often.. ^^
The italic words are the food (bait) and the ones below are the fish that you can catch!!

Apple
Applefish
Sea Urchin
Carp
Clownfish
Empty Bottle
Old Boot
Starfish (purple)
Silver Arowana
Soda Can
Sea Star Baby Doll
Fish Bones
Squid (pink)
Green Discus
Octopus
Clown Knifefish
Blowfish
Blue Gill
Lovefish
Sheepfish

Banana
Soda Can
Conch Shell
Bike Wheel
Broken Pot
Sea Urchin

Birthday Cake
Starfish (purple)
Birthdaycake fish
Macaronfish

Biscuit
Paddlefish
Coral
Fish Bones
Soda Can
Starfish (purple)
Crab
Sea Star Baby Doll
Bike Wheel
Conch Shell
Message in a Bottle
Blowfish

Blue Ribbon Cupcake
Blue Gill

Bone
Puppyfish
Starfish (purple)
Octopus

Broccoli
Altum Angelfish
Bluegill
Seaweed
Empty Bottle
Conch Shell
Clown Fish
Coral

Carrot
Altum angelfish
Coral
Empty bottle
Fish bone
Paddle fish
Starfish (purple)
Sardine
Soda can
Squid (pink)
Seaweed
Seahorse
Silver arowana
Bike Wheel
Octopus
Dogfish
Frontosal

Cauliflower
Message in a Bottle
Conch Shell
Fish Bones
Sea Urchin
Sardine

Cheese
Bike Wheel
Old Boot
Altum Angelfish
Flounder
Crab
Conch Shell
Soda Can
Message in a Bottle
Silver Arowana
Seaweed
Squid (pink)
Paddlefish
Cheesefish
Blowfish
Broken Pot
Sea Urchin
Empty Bottle
Elephantnose Fish
Amberstone Bug

Cheeseburger
Sardine
Shrimp
Silver Arowana
Fish Bones
Starfish (purple)

Chocolate Donut
Clownfish
Crab
Altum Angelfish
Flounder
Sardine

Chocolate Heart
Chocolate Fish

Chocolate Ice Cream
Old Boot

Chocolate Milk
Shrimp

Chocolate Poo
Bike Wheel

Coconut
Empty Bottle
Paddlefish
Coral
Sardine
Altum Angelfish
Fish Bone
Squid (pink)

Coconut Juice
Elephantnose Fish

Corn
Sea Star Baby Doll
Conch Shell
Crab
Altum Angelfish
Octopus
Fish Bones
Soda Can
Message in a bottle
Dogfish
Seaweed
Bike Wheel
Frontosa
Coral
Sea Urchin
Empty bottle

Courgette
Broken Pot
Bike Wheel
Sea Star Baby Doll
Message in a Bottle
Seaweed

Fish Biscuit (from Cash Shop)
Black Angelfish
Blue Betta
Daifuku Mochifish
Lilac Starletfish

Grapes
Paddlefish
Broken Pot
Shrimp
Bluegill
Soda Can

Homegrown Apple
Starfish (purple)
Squid (pink)
Sardine
Elephantnose Fish

Homegrown Banana
Squid (pink)
Starfish (purple)
Banana Fish

Homegrown Beet Root
Starfish (purple)

Homegrown Carrot
Squid (pink)
Starfish (purple)

Homegrown Cherry
Squid

Homegrown Coconut
Coconut Fish
Octopus

Homegrown Cupcake
Squid (pink)
Starfish (purple)
Cupcake fish

Homegrown Orange
Starfish (purple)
Orange fish

Homegrown Sweetheart Root
Loverootfish

Hot Dog
Fish Bones
Broken Pot
Coral
Message in a Bottle

Ice Cream Sundae
Starfish (purple)

Leek
Sea Star Baby Doll
Old Boot
Fish Bones

Lemon
Empty Bottle
Crab
Coral
Altum Angelfish

Loaf of Bread
Message in a Bottle
Starfish (purple)
Flounder
Fish Bones
Frontosa
Bike Wheel
Broken Pot
Sea Urchin
Coral
Seaweed
Crab
Conch Shell
Empty Bottle

Love Heart Lolli
Soda Can

Maple Syrup
Crab
Silver Arowana
Flounder

Meatball
Seaweed
Fish Bones
Old Boot
Squid (pink)

Melon
Sea Star Baby Doll
Broken Pot
Fish Bones
Paddlefish
Message in a Bottle
Crab
Soda Can
Empty Bottle
Seaweed
Black Ghost Knifefish

Milk
Shrimp
Crab
Paddlefish
Bluegill
Flounder
Blue Ram

Onion
Flounder
Old Boot
Conch Shell
Sardine
Altum Angelfish
Sea Star Baby Doll
Sea Urchin
Frontosa

Orange Juice
Conch Shell
Seaweed
Shrimp
Clownfish
Carp

Peach Syrup
Starfish

Pear
Coral
Starfish (purple)
Fish Bones
Bluegill
Squid (pink)
Empty Bottle
Conch Shell
Paddlefish
Flounder

Pineapple
Sea Urchin
Starfish (purple)
Empty Bottle
Sardine

Pink Donut
Flounder
Carp
Shrimp
Frontosa
Paddlefish
Bluegill
Altum Angelfish
Sardine
Starfish (purple)
Squid (pink)
Clownfish
Crab
Silver Arowana
Strawberry Donutfish
Green Discus
Blue Ram
Shrimp
Blowfish
Lovefish

Pizza, Full
Starfish (purple)
Squid (pink)

Pizza, Slice
Clownfish
Frontosa
Flounder
Squid (pink)
Conch Shell

Popcorn
Seaweed
Bike Wheel
Message in a Bottle
Flounder
Squid

Prinscorv
Fish Bones

Pumpkin
Seaweed
Squid (pink)
Conch Shell
Old Boot
Broken Pot

Rare Steak
Soda Can
Shrimp
Broken Pot
Sea Star Baby Doll
Sea Urchin
Old Boots
Conch Shell

Salami
Soda Can
Flounder

Samosa
Clam with Pearl
Lovefish
Blue Sea Urchin Shell

Shamrock Lollipop
Sea Star Baby Doll

Strawberry
Sea Star Baby Doll
Soda Can
Fish Bones
Old Boot
Bike Wheel
Bluegill
Strawberryfish

Watermelon
Conch Shell
Bike Wheel
Coral
Silver Arowana
Watermelonfish
Green Discus

From Pet Society Addicts and Fishing for Dummies in Pet Society. Some others are from my own fishing experiences

Feel free to add some baits and catches if it is not in the list.. ^^